Brenda invites Kelly, Donna and Andrea over for a "night of female bonding". They are having a fab time until Kelly's mean friend Amanda shows up. She insults everyone and decides to turn the girls against each other. As part of a "game" about secrets, Amanda bullies Kelly into describing her first sexual encounter, in which she was humiliated by the football captain. After Brenda recalls stealing a Minnesota friend's boyfriend, Kelly admits that she tried to hit on Dylan but was brutally rebuffed and Brenda is livid with her now former BFF. The girls eventually make up, and Brenda and Kelly vow to never let a man come between them. Amanda's behavior is discovered to be the result of a diet pill addiction.
The girls also catch David and Scott lurking outside the window of the Walsh house, taking pictures of them. Brandon and Steve are denied entry to a club, but hook up with two girls in the parking lot, who convince Steve to let them drive his Corvette alone. The conniving duo steal his car, but once it's found, he decides not to press charges (and pays their traffic ticket) because he foolishly thinks that he and Brandon might still have a chance with them.
- Jason Priestley as Brandon Walsh
- Shannen Doherty as Brenda Walsh
- Jennie Garth as Kelly Taylor
- Ian Ziering as Steve Sanders
- Gabrielle Carteris as Andrea Zuckerman
- Luke Perry as Dylan McKay
- Brian Austin Green as David Silver
- Douglas Emerson as Scott Scanlon
- Tori Spelling as Donna Martin
- Carol Potter as Cindy Walsh
- and James Eckhouse as Jim Walsh
- Michele Abrams as Amanda Peyser
- Julie McCullough as Trina
- Judie Aronson as Shelly